Episode 79

full
Published on:

17th Nov 2026

Michael Dubis — Inside Jeffrey Dahmer's Apartment the Night of the Arrest | Part 1

Michael Dubis is a retired Milwaukee Police lieutenant from a police family: his father, his sister and his brother-in-law all wore the uniform, and his nephew still does. In July 1991 he was working the midnight shift in the homicide unit when his lieutenant sent him and his partner, Detective Pat Kennedy, to an apartment where officers had found photographs of dismembered bodies. It was Jeffrey Dahmer's.

He walks hosts Dennis Collins, Craig Floyd and Bill Erfurth through that night: Dahmer handcuffed on the floor, the refrigerator an officer told him to check first, and the human head inside it. He describes how Dahmer came to be caught, after a man he had handcuffed broke away and ran into a Milwaukee police squad car, and how calm Dahmer was once detectives arrived.

Mike explains why neighbors' complaints went to the landlord instead of the police, how detectives worked through about 84 Polaroid pictures and hundreds of missing-person reports, and how Dahmer himself picked out his victims from photographs. Sixteen victims were in Milwaukee County and one in Bath, Ohio.

The hardest part, he says, came afterward. The six months after the arrest were the hardest of his 46-year marriage, not because of what he saw in the apartment but because of how the media treated his department. In 1991, records were kept on 3x5 cards and manual typewriters, a point he makes to college students who ask why detectives didn't do more.

Part 2 covers what the case cost the detectives who worked it, a psychiatrist who had seen one autopsy, and Officer Michael Michalski.

New episodes drop on Tuesdays and Thursdays. Subscribe wherever you listen to podcasts.

Learn more at citizensbehindthebadge.org.

© 2026 Citizens Behind the Badge. All Rights Reserved.

Transcript
Speaker:

This episode includes detailed descriptions of homicide

Speaker:

victims and human remains.

Speaker:

Discretion is advised.

Speaker:

It wasn't what I saw in Dahmer's apartment.

Speaker:

It wasn't the heads that were in the freezer.

Speaker:

Uh, it was how the media, local, national, worldly, uh,

Speaker:

the media was, uh, berating my, my dear police department

Speaker:

You've heard us mention many times on this podcast,

Speaker:

the average person faces three or four traumatic

Speaker:

events in their lifetime.

Speaker:

The average police officer, 400 to 600 in a career.

Speaker:

And then, of course, there's always that one that stands

Speaker:

out above all the rest.

Speaker:

We're going back to July 1991 today.

Speaker:

Our guest today was a Milwaukee homicide detective, one of

Speaker:

the very first to arrive at the Jeffrey Dahmer apartment,

Speaker:

a place that Time Magazine described at the time as

Speaker:

a private slaughterhouse.

Speaker:

Michael Dubis, welcome to Heroes Behind the Badge.

Speaker:

Thank you, gentlemen.

Speaker:

We're glad to have you here.

Speaker:

Tell us, what is it that you walked into that night in July of

Speaker:

1991, and what did that do to you?

Speaker:

Well, I was assigned to the homicide unit

Speaker:

on the midnight shift.

Speaker:

And, uh, just any other night, um, at one point right around

Speaker:

midnight, shortly after midnight, our lieutenant came back, Rosie

Speaker:

Harrell, and says, "Hey, guys."

Speaker:

Before midnight he sent out a detective, Jim Devalkenaere,

Speaker:

out to an apartment.

Speaker:

The officers that were there said they found some pictures

Speaker:

with dead, carved up dead bodies in the pictures.

Speaker:

Wow.

Speaker:

And they looked real.

Speaker:

Wow.

Speaker:

And, uh, so Devalkenaere went out to… was on his way to the

Speaker:

scene, and the officers called back and said now they had found

Speaker:

a human head in the refrigerator.

Speaker:

And Lieutenant Harrell says, "Guys, go out there, find out

Speaker:

what's really going on, and call me back right away." Um,

Speaker:

so I grabbed a fresh steno pad, and my partner, Detective Pat

Speaker:

Kennedy, and I, I can remember driving up State Street heading

Speaker:

toward the apartment building, it wasn't far from the police

Speaker:

station, and talking about what might we find when we get there.

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

And it was what it was.

Speaker:

Uh, I remember walking into the apartment.

Speaker:

Uh, Dahmer was handcuffed, uh, on the floor.

Speaker:

Um, officers were standing nearby.

Speaker:

And, uh- I asked if, uh, they wanted to get him up and we could

Speaker:

talk and see what's going on.

Speaker:

I remember one of the officers telling me, "Well, go check

Speaker:

the refrigerator first."

Speaker:

And I opened up the refrigerator and there was a, a human head in

Speaker:

a cardboard box looking at me.

Speaker:

Oh, God.

Speaker:

And, uh, I said, "Just leave him where he's at."

Speaker:

And, uh, at that point, um, obviously we had a homicide.

Speaker:

Obviously we had a lot of protocols and rules to follow.

Speaker:

Um, the officers had swept the apartment to make sure there

Speaker:

was no other injured bodies, injured people in there,

Speaker:

no other suspects in there.

Speaker:

At that point, uh, we called our boss to tell him what we

Speaker:

had and, and, uh, start getting some medical investigators

Speaker:

and a district attorney awake, uh, with the possibilities of,

Speaker:

uh, expecting to get a search warrant for the apartment.

Speaker:

Had you ever seen anything like that, Michael, before?

Speaker:

Was that… I mean, maybe that's a silly question, but-

Speaker:

Well, at that point I'd been on the homicide unit for

Speaker:

about a year and a half.

Speaker:

Right.

Speaker:

Um, keeping in mind, gentlemen, that, um, 1988, the city of

Speaker:

Milwaukee had 84 homicides.

Speaker:

Uh, by two- by, uh, 1991, we were up to 165 homicides.

Speaker:

Wow.

Speaker:

Crack cocaine had hit the streets of Milwaukee.

Speaker:

Oh, boy.

Speaker:

And, um, so we were going every night, every night, every night.

Speaker:

Um, had I seen something like that before this happened?

Speaker:

I'd had a couple of scenes already involving small children.

Speaker:

And as, as horrific as this was, um, I think we can all agree

Speaker:

that, uh, dealing with small children under the age of three

Speaker:

that were homicide victims, um, was a little tougher.

Speaker:

I would think, yeah,

Speaker:

yeah.

Speaker:

What, what, what led to the fact, uh, that you all got

Speaker:

entry into Dahmer's apartment?

Speaker:

I'm sure he didn't invite you in.

Speaker:

How did it come about that you ended up in the

Speaker:

apartment that night?

Speaker:

So Dahmer had picked up, uh, a date, uh, a friend, a person to

Speaker:

take back to the apartment, and they were gonna have a couple

Speaker:

of beers in the apartment.

Speaker:

Um, Dahmer, uh, was always into, um, bondage with his partners.

Speaker:

Oh.

Speaker:

And, uh, the man had been handcuffed.

Speaker:

And at some point, he just wasn't feeling very comfortable with

Speaker:

what was going on, and he was able to break away, get out of the

Speaker:

apartment building, and run out into the street where he wa- ran

Speaker:

into a Milwaukee Police squad car.

Speaker:

Um, and he asked the officers if they could use their

Speaker:

He didn't say anything about what was going on in the apartment.

Speaker:

He just wanted to get out of the handcuffs.

Speaker:

And, uh, their key wouldn't unlock the handcuffs, so they

Speaker:

took him back up to the apartment.

Speaker:

And so when they got up there, obviously, uh,

Speaker:

Dahmer's still there, right?

Speaker:

Yep.

Speaker:

He opened up the door.

Speaker:

Wow.

Speaker:

The officers, uh, asked him about the handcuffs and a

Speaker:

handcuff key, and Dahmer was pretty, pretty calm.

Speaker:

At that point, nobody, not even the, uh, person in

Speaker:

handcuffs, uh, nobody had seen any pictures, nobody had seen

Speaker:

what was in the refrigerator.

Speaker:

And I think Dahmer was pretty comfortable with, "Well, nobody

Speaker:

knows what's going on, I'm just gonna play this out." Um, and, uh,

Speaker:

uh, at that point he went looking for the keys to the handcuffs.

Speaker:

Um, one of the officers happened to be standing sort of centrally

Speaker:

located in the apartment, and as he glanced over to his

Speaker:

right, he saw the first four Polaroid pictures that were on

Speaker:

top of a dresser, and, uh, saw that, uh, it was a human body,

Speaker:

uh, hanging from the shower.

Speaker:

Um, and it, uh, at that point, uh, they decided that,

Speaker:

uh, they needed to do more.

Speaker:

Wow.

Speaker:

Wow.

Speaker:

And M- Mike, was Dahmer saying anything while you all were there?

Speaker:

Uh, as you uncovered all this, uh, uh, atrocious, uh,

Speaker:

you know, uh, heads in the refrigerator, bones everywhere.

Speaker:

I mean, what's Dahmer saying at this point?

Speaker:

Nothing.

Speaker:

Nothing.

Speaker:

Um, he, uh … Soon after Lieutenant Harrell arrives on

Speaker:

the scene, Dahmer was removed.

Speaker:

Um, Detective Pat Kennedy went down to start talking to him.

Speaker:

Uh, so for the first, uh, interviews, Dahmer was-

Speaker:

Happy that it was over.

Speaker:

Happy that he was caught, uh, if the word happy is correct.

Speaker:

Happy that, that the evil that he had in his mind, the, the pain

Speaker:

that he was going through as he was doing these things was over.

Speaker:

He'd been caught.

Speaker:

It was done.

Speaker:

And at that point, uh, Kennedy, uh, advised him

Speaker:

of his rights, told him what the, his options were.

Speaker:

And Dahmer signed, uh, Pat Kennedy's book giving us

Speaker:

permission to, uh, search the apartment, take evidence.

Speaker:

And by then, uh, Dr. Jeffrey Jentzen, the head medical examiner,

Speaker:

had already arrived on the scene.

Speaker:

And, uh, the district attorney's office was,

Speaker:

uh, awake and ready to go.

Speaker:

Again, this is like, you know, 1:30, 2:00 on a, on a

Speaker:

Tuesday morning I think it was.

Speaker:

Um, and, uh, so Dahmer didn't say much.

Speaker:

He didn't, he didn't demand we leave.

Speaker:

He didn't demand that we stop looking anywhere.

Speaker:

Um, he was, he was pretty calm.

Speaker:

And so at that point, Mike, how many bodies or homicide victims

Speaker:

were identified initially?

Speaker:

Well, we, once we had permission to search the

Speaker:

apartment, um, we, uh, had the one in the refrigerator.

Speaker:

There were packages in the freezer that looked like meat.

Speaker:

Um, I hunt.

Speaker:

I got a freezer full of deer meat.

Speaker:

Um, but these were in clear plastic resealable bags.

Speaker:

Um, we had not looked into the … I'm sorry.

Speaker:

We had not looked into the, um

Speaker:

Give me one second.

Speaker:

I'm sorry.

Speaker:

We had not looked into the, uh, chest freezer yet.

Speaker:

Um, we did have, uh, about 84 Polaroid pictures.

Speaker:

And, uh, Polaroid pictures were of all sorts of, uh,

Speaker:

pieces, parts, dead bodies, skulls, male genitalia, um,

Speaker:

bodies that had been skinned.

Speaker:

And, uh, um, so w- we had, we just had the one, and

Speaker:

then we had all the pictures.

Speaker:

If you believe the pictures were, were real, we probably

Speaker:

had about eight or, eight or nine more at that point.

Speaker:

So let me ask you this.

Speaker:

You know, I've been on a number of homicide scenes

Speaker:

or dead body scenes.

Speaker:

You know, we talk about smoking cigars and using Vicks on your lip

Speaker:

so that you can't smell the smell.

Speaker:

What did his apartment look like?

Speaker:

What did it smell like?

Speaker:

Was it, was it kind of a discombobulated hell hole,

Speaker:

or was he a neat guy?

Speaker:

How did it smell?

Speaker:

Just, just describe all that.

Speaker:

He was a relatively neat guy.

Speaker:

Um, he's a single guy, so it wasn't, uh, it wasn't, um, wiped

Speaker:

down clean every single day.

Speaker:

Um, but, uh, there weren't any clothes laying around.

Speaker:

There were a few beer cans that might have been there

Speaker:

from him and, uh, his buddy.

Speaker:

Um, uh, it, it was in relatively good condition

Speaker:

It didn't smell, you didn't have that dead body smell when you walk

Speaker:

in or some kinda odd, uh, scent?

Speaker:

Um, if you remember the stories, uh, Dahmer used a lot

Speaker:

of chemicals to melt down the bones, uh, early on when he

Speaker:

was, um, doing his, his evil.

Speaker:

And, uh, so the, the apartment had a very strong

Speaker:

chemical sweet smell.

Speaker:

Um, it wasn't, uh, it wasn't repugnant.

Speaker:

It wa- it wasn't, uh, like a dead body had been there for 10 days

Speaker:

in July closed up in the heat.

Speaker:

Um, it was sweet.

Speaker:

Um, and it wasn't, it wasn't offensive, I'll say that.

Speaker:

Hmm.

Speaker:

Interesting.

Speaker:

Interesting.

Speaker:

Mike, why, um, did it take so long to catch this guy?

Speaker:

His neighbors, you know, in, in subsequent interviews, um,

Speaker:

complained of loud noises late at night, uh, sounds of saws,

Speaker:

um, other machinery of that type, um, and, and strange odors.

Speaker:

Did they ever complain to the police?

Speaker:

Did- was it ever brought to your attention?

Speaker:

I mean, the guy killed several victims in one

Speaker:

week, as I understand, um, and it went on for a while.

Speaker:

Um, uh, yeah, wh- what was the reason why he, uh, was allowed

Speaker:

to murder people for so long?

Speaker:

It seems like he should've been caught sooner.

Speaker:

Well, most of all of those complaints went to the landlord.

Speaker:

Hmm.

Speaker:

And as long as Jeffrey was paying his rent on time, the landlord

Speaker:

wasn't really interested in, um, complaining to the police.

Speaker:

Uh- Hmm … you can only imagine, if we come and kick him out or,

Speaker:

you know, wind up finding what we found and arresting him, well,

Speaker:

now he's gotta find somebody to, um, start paying that rent again.

Speaker:

Um, I don't recall how often the police might have been

Speaker:

called to that apartment, to that specific apartment.

Speaker:

Um, keeping in mind that there were, uh, probably 16 to 20 units

Speaker:

there, and the police get called to apartment buildings, as you

Speaker:

may know, all the time for this apartment or that apartment.

Speaker:

It isn't that unusual to get sent to loud musics, um, or,

Speaker:

or arguments or fights or noise, uh, middle of the night.

Speaker:

Tell 'em to knock it off and be done with it.

Speaker:

Um, I don't even see a reason to go into the apartment.

Speaker:

You go talk to, to a person who answers the door.

Speaker:

He's, he's reasonable, he's decent.

Speaker:

He says, "Yeah, sure.

Speaker:

I'll, I'll turn the music down," or, or, "I'll stop whatever I'm

Speaker:

doing for the night." That's, that's what you're there to do,

Speaker:

and that's what they got done.

Speaker:

So, uh, at that point there hadn't been a whole lot of- contact with

Speaker:

Jeffrey Dahmer at that apartment building to, uh, cause us to

Speaker:

go in and start looking around.

Speaker:

And, and even if you would've gone into his apartment, for

Speaker:

whatever reason, other than the smell, and again, it wasn't that

Speaker:

of a dead body, um, you can't go looking in his dresser drawers.

Speaker:

You can't go looking in the refrigerator, you know, without,

Speaker:

without some sort of reason, so.

Speaker:

So my quick question- Yeah … I mean, he was, he was referred

Speaker:

to as the, the Cannibal Killer.

Speaker:

I know there was a documentary.

Speaker:

There's been all kinds of stuff.

Speaker:

I personally don't watch all that.

Speaker:

You know, wh- when you've been a cop and done, done

Speaker:

things, uh, I don't know.

Speaker:

I, I don't, I don't watch those kind of shows anymore.

Speaker:

But, uh, maybe, maybe it's been out there.

Speaker:

But at what point and how, uh, did you know that he was, uh,

Speaker:

was eating some of these victims?

Speaker:

I, I recall even him putting some body parts in boiling pots and

Speaker:

boiling them and, and eating it.

Speaker:

So, um, and I haven't read all the, uh, statements recently.

Speaker:

I know that there is one statement where he did admit trying to, uh,

Speaker:

eat, uh, somebody's body part.

Speaker:

Uh, a muscle of some sort, uh, was fairly tough and,

Speaker:

uh, he didn't finish it.

Speaker:

Um, there were body parts in a kettle that were in

Speaker:

the closet that we found.

Speaker:

Um, as far as boiling things, I don't, I don't remember that.

Speaker:

Um, he, uh, uh, he was always on the go.

Speaker:

He was in and out of his apartment.

Speaker:

Um-

Speaker:

How about some of the, the behind-the-scenes talk?

Speaker:

You know, I, I, I know all of you guys, you work a-

Speaker:

as a team on a homicide and you're all sitting together.

Speaker:

At what point do you just sit back and, and you're all together

Speaker:

and you're working to put this whole case together for trial

Speaker:

and whatnot, what were some of those conversations like?

Speaker:

I mean, were you guys just like, "Wow, this guy is an absolute

Speaker:

freak. What the hell's going on here?" Um, any, any kinda

Speaker:

conversations that you recall?

Speaker:

Well, um, as, as I, uh, talked about the people that were there,

Speaker:

um, Jim Devalkenaere did a lot of the, um, running around FBI

Speaker:

crime lab type stuff like that.

Speaker:

Um, I was always the dot your I, cross the T, make

Speaker:

sure everything's, uh, written down accurately.

Speaker:

And, uh, my partner that night, uh, Pat Kennedy,

Speaker:

he was the gumshoe.

Speaker:

He could talk to anybody and get them to cooperate, tell

Speaker:

'em what he wanted to know.

Speaker:

So I, you know, Pat and I used each other for what we had.

Speaker:

I did the, did the, uh, paperwork, and he did a lot

Speaker:

of the talking to people.

Speaker:

Um, you know what?

Speaker:

I think everybody took it so serious realizing what we had

Speaker:

that there really wasn't a lot of, um, joking around or, uh, even

Speaker:

off-color, uh, comments like that.

Speaker:

It was like, "You know, we've got weeks of work ahead of us here.

Speaker:

Let's get this done." Um, I went into work that night at, uh,

Speaker:

quarter to 12, and I didn't come home till 7:00 PM that next night.

Speaker:

Um, and I was back at it at 6:00 the next morning.

Speaker:

Um, keeping in mind that as you go through, with his permission,

Speaker:

and we recovered everything from the house, in his dresser drawers,

Speaker:

every piece of paper was either a prescription for some sort of

Speaker:

psy- psychiatric drugs or a, uh, uh, appointment for a psychiatric

Speaker:

doctor or a medical doctor.

Speaker:

Every one of those pieces of paper had to be, um, inventoried

Speaker:

as a separate item and documented as to what you had 'cause you

Speaker:

really didn't know, um, which doctor was gonna tell us something

Speaker:

and, and I had no idea what those drugs were all about.

Speaker:

So somebody's gonna have to review, uh, each piece

Speaker:

of paper as to what it was.

Speaker:

So, um, I literally was inventorying stuff from

Speaker:

each drawer for weeks.

Speaker:

Um, put it in-

Speaker:

Mike, you, you know, you, you said you got home the

Speaker:

next night at 7:00 PM.

Speaker:

I'm just wondering, what's that like?

Speaker:

Uh, I, I, I don't know i- if you have a wife, kids

Speaker:

at home at this point.

Speaker:

Um, but w- what is that like after discovering what you discovered

Speaker:

at Jeffrey Dahmer's apartment, going through all the work that

Speaker:

was involved to process the case, now you go home to your family.

Speaker:

Um, do you talk to them about what you've experienced, what you saw?

Speaker:

Um, h- h- what does that go like?

Speaker:

So, um, a- as we've talked before we got on the air today, um,

Speaker:

I come from a police family.

Speaker:

Uh, my father was a, a police officer.

Speaker:

Uh, my sister Karen, when she retired, was a lieutenant.

Speaker:

I have a brother-in-law who was a police officer, and I have

Speaker:

a nephew who's still there.

Speaker:

Um, there's a lot of officers that don't tell their wives anything.

Speaker:

Um, when the family gets together, there's five of us

Speaker:

that are, you know, wearing uniforms and carrying a gun.

Speaker:

Um, we talk openly and, um, so I found it that it was

Speaker:

better for my wife to know what I was dealing with.

Speaker:

Um-

Speaker:

I will share that the six months after Jeffrey Dahmer's arrest

Speaker:

were probably the six hardest months of my married life, and

Speaker:

I've been married now 46 years.

Speaker:

Um, and it wasn't Dahmer's apartment.

Speaker:

It wasn't what I saw in Dahmer's apartment.

Speaker:

It wasn't the heads that were in the freezer.

Speaker:

Uh, it was how the media, local, national, worldly, uh,

Speaker:

the media was, uh, berating my, my dear police department, um,

Speaker:

and how we were being treated.

Speaker:

Uh, keeping in mind, gentlemen, this is 1991.

Speaker:

We didn't have computers.

Speaker:

Everything was either on three by five cards or filed

Speaker:

by hand alphabetically by month, by d- day, by year.

Speaker:

Um, so, uh, there's a lot of questions that I've, uh, talked

Speaker:

to like college students when I've helped with different programs,

Speaker:

and, um, they say, "Well, why didn't you do this or do that?"

Speaker:

And they don't understand it was three by five cards.

Speaker:

It was manual typewriters, and that's how, you know, things

Speaker:

were being searched and filed.

Speaker:

And, uh, um, so, uh, the hard part- Mike,

Speaker:

tell us, tell us more specifically what was going on with the media.

Speaker:

Yeah, I'd like to hear about that.

Speaker:

Um- Boy.

Speaker:

Well, you, you, I'm s- you may have heard about, uh, the Asian

Speaker:

boy, Konerak Sinthasomphone, um, who was, uh, a Dahmer victim.

Speaker:

Uh, in May of 1991, um, the police were called to the apartment

Speaker:

building, um, for a fight, and the fight was actually in the hallway

Speaker:

or out front of the building.

Speaker:

Um, uniformed officers rolled up on it, and, uh, Konerak

Speaker:

Sinthasomphone, who they report to be 14 years old, um, was, uh,

Speaker:

wearing a, a pair of underwear.

Speaker:

That's all he had on.

Speaker:

You know, he was drunk.

Speaker:

Uh, he was, uh, unable to, uh, converse very

Speaker:

well with the officers.

Speaker:

Jeffrey Dahmer's there.

Speaker:

He says, "This is my, my lover. This is my friend, and, uh, he's

Speaker:

drunk. I'll just take him back inside the apartment." Uh, at

Speaker:

which point the officers got a couple of names and, and sent, uh,

Speaker:

Konerak back into the apartment building with Jeffrey Dahmer.

Speaker:

Um- Monday morning quarterbacks, you know, can, can think all

Speaker:

sorts of things, uh, three months later and say how the officers

Speaker:

should have handled that.

Speaker:

Uh, S- Konerak was, uh, extremely physically fit.

Speaker:

Uh, from the pictures that I saw that I, you know,

Speaker:

that were in some of the Polaroids that were there.

Speaker:

Uh, somebody says he's 14.

Speaker:

Um, could he have been 18?

Speaker:

He could have been.

Speaker:

Um, yeah, I'm not here to, to second guess those officers.

Speaker:

They made the best, uh, decision with the information they had.

Speaker:

And, uh, so they returned Konerak back to Jeffrey Dahmer,

Speaker:

who ultimately takes him back upstairs and kills him.

Speaker:

Wow.

Speaker:

And, uh-

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

… so that, that didn't go well.

Speaker:

The fact that there were, um, 16 victims in the Milwaukee

Speaker:

County area, 13 in Milwaukee City, three in West Allis,

Speaker:

um, why didn't the police do something about this before?

Speaker:

Um, in the follow-up investigations afterwards,

Speaker:

uh, Kennedy and I had spent time in the gay community, in

Speaker:

some of the taverns that were frequented by, uh, men and, uh,

Speaker:

they didn't wanna talk to us.

Speaker:

Uh, they often referred to a, a white ghost who would come into

Speaker:

some of the bars, leave with one of the patrons, and nobody'd

Speaker:

ever see that patron again.

Speaker:

Oh.

Speaker:

But, uh, they really couldn't give us a description.

Speaker:

Nobody ever called the police on him.

Speaker:

Um, it never was that big of a deal outside of

Speaker:

their little community.

Speaker:

And, uh, so, um-

Speaker:

So how did the media treat you specifically?

Speaker:

Did you ever have much interaction with them?

Speaker:

No.

Speaker:

I didn't talk to them.

Speaker:

Uh-

Speaker:

You wanted nothing to do with them … at the time, you're right, at the

Speaker:

time I was a detective, um, the, the, the police chief, uh, the

Speaker:

captain in charge of homicides, the, they were the ones that were,

Speaker:

um, handling questions and stuff.

Speaker:

The district attorney, E. Michael McCann, uh,

Speaker:

was answering questions.

Speaker:

Um, as a detective back then, I didn't get

Speaker:

involved in any of that.

Speaker:

So- Uh, but it, it, it just hurt.

Speaker:

It just … You know, we were doing everything we

Speaker:

could and, and, uh, they weren't happy with it.

Speaker:

Well, yeah.

Speaker:

Th- th- I mean, even to this day they second-guess a lot

Speaker:

of things the police do, and that's what this podcast

Speaker:

is all about, actually.

Speaker:

To tell the truth, and to get the truth out there about what's

Speaker:

really going on in policing, and not the media narrative.

Speaker:

Let me remind our, uh, our audience, this podcast

Speaker:

is brought to you by Citizens Behind the Badge.

Speaker:

CitizensBehindTheBadge.org, the leading organization in

Speaker:

support of the men and women of law enforcement in the

Speaker:

United States of America.

Speaker:

You can get involved.

Speaker:

CitizensBehindTheBadge.org.

Speaker:

You can subscribe, like and follow this podcast.

Speaker:

You'll always be the first to know when the next episode's coming

Speaker:

up, and you can get involved in our mission and sign a declaration

Speaker:

of support for our police.

Speaker:

It's more important than ever right now, so get involved.

Speaker:

CitizensBehindTheBadge.org.

Speaker:

Uh, Mike, I was gonna ask you a question.

Speaker:

With all these dismembered bodies, how the heck did you

Speaker:

guys identify these victims?

Speaker:

I mean, I don't know what the state of DNA was back in that

Speaker:

day, but it would seem to me that would be a monumental task

Speaker:

So, um, many of the victims were identified by Jeffrey himself.

Speaker:

Um, as we, uh, had families coming to us and talking

Speaker:

about their missing loved one.

Speaker:

Um, we, we probably investigated hundreds of missings.

Speaker:

Right.

Speaker:

Uh, family members who told us that they had a, uh, a family

Speaker:

member who was gay who hadn't been seen in weeks or months,

Speaker:

uh, might have disappeared over the last two or three years.

Speaker:

Many of them we found in Chicago or Detroit or Gary, Indiana.

Speaker:

Um, I remember taking calls from as far away as, uh, uh, France

Speaker:

and Germany, uh, detectives who wanted us to show Dahmer pictures,

Speaker:

um, and they would send them over.

Speaker:

Um, many of the pictures, uh, Dahmer would, uh, pick

Speaker:

out his victim, um, and say, "Yep, you know, I got him,

Speaker:

picked him up on this day.

Speaker:

I picked him up on that day." Dahmer knew, he had dates and

Speaker:

places of all the different, um-

Speaker:

Wow

Speaker:

… victims that he had.

Speaker:

And he remembered these guys just by looking at the photo?

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

Uh, there was even one victim who at birth only had one kidney.

Speaker:

It was in the missing report when the family reported him missing.

Speaker:

The officers even wrote it down.

Speaker:

Ironically enough, as Dahmer's looking at pictures, um, he

Speaker:

points out that picture and says, "You know, that guy was unusual.

Speaker:

He only had one kidney." And officer, the, uh, p- Detective

Speaker:

Dennis Murphy, who was doing the interviews with him at

Speaker:

this point, you know, was like, "Well, how do you know

Speaker:

what a kidney looks like?"

Speaker:

Well, when Dahmer was in the Army, in the military, um,

Speaker:

he was trained as a medic.

Speaker:

Wow.

Speaker:

And so he had had all sorts of different, um, uh, physiology

Speaker:

type, uh, trainings and information, and, uh, he, you

Speaker:

know, so things like that, um,

Speaker:

So quick, quick question while we're on that.

Speaker:

Did he know he only had one kidney because the guy

Speaker:

told him that or because he dismembered it, dismembered him

Speaker:

and found that to be the case?

Speaker:

When he dismembered him and, and, uh, took him in pieces,

Speaker:

and only found one in there.

Speaker:

Wow, that's crazy.

Speaker:

I'm wondering how much did the families know, uh, about

Speaker:

all of this, uh, about the, um, the terrible condition

Speaker:

of, of the bodies, the skulls, the dismemberment.

Speaker:

I mean, uh, when you went to talk to the families to explain

Speaker:

that you found their loved one dead, did, did they get

Speaker:

the details and, and what was their reaction to all of this?

Speaker:

They were horrified.

Speaker:

They, they couldn't believe that it happened to them, to

Speaker:

one of their family members.

Speaker:

Um, we shared whatever they asked for.

Speaker:

Um, a lot of the immediate identification of each victim,

Speaker:

along with Detective Murphy's, uh, showing pictures and Dahmer

Speaker:

saying, "I killed him and him and him." Um, the medical

Speaker:

examiner also goes through a process of identifying

Speaker:

victims with the family so that, so that they make their

Speaker:

own next of kin notification.

Speaker:

Um, some of the bodies we never recovered.

Speaker:

Some of them were melted down and flushed down the toilet,

Speaker:

uh, melted down in the ba- uh, blue barrel of acid.

Speaker:

And, uh, um, so we could only go on what, who Dahmer identified

Speaker:

as who his victims were.

Speaker:

And if you looked at a picture and says, "No, I

Speaker:

never saw that guy before," you know, that's what we had.

Speaker:

So we have 16 victims in Milwaukee County.

Speaker:

We have one in Bath, Ohio, and who knows if there were more.

Speaker:

Um, he didn't ident- He didn't tell us about any more.

Speaker:

He didn't identify any more.

Speaker:

Um, but, uh, 17-

Speaker:

Do you think po- potentially there were more?

Speaker:

There could have been.

Speaker:

Um, uh, it's, it's in the reports.

Speaker:

I'm not saying anything that's not out there.

Speaker:

But, uh, when Dahmer was in Germany in the Army, um, there

Speaker:

were six women, six prostitutes in Germany that were found, uh,

Speaker:

in different states of being decapitated right near the

Speaker:

military base where Dahmer was at.

Speaker:

Now he denied it over and over and over, said he

Speaker:

never killed any women.

Speaker:

He didn't like women.

Speaker:

Um, but you just gotta wonder.

Speaker:

You put your cop hat on and you wonder, you know, 'cause

Speaker:

while he was there, it occurred.

Speaker:

When he left, when he got kicked out of the Army,

Speaker:

um, for alcohol problems, um, those murders stopped.

Speaker:

And you just gotta ask yourself.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

So a, a follow-up question.

Speaker:

When you were saying that you had gone to a number of these bars,

Speaker:

there wasn't a lot of cooperation.

Speaker:

They didn't really wanna talk to you, but they referred to this

Speaker:

figure as kind of a, a ghost.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Did they know some of these victims, though?

Speaker:

Like you said, they all of a sudden, they realized these people

Speaker:

never came back to the bars again.

Speaker:

But some people that go to bars over and over and over,

Speaker:

they know the bartenders, the waitresses, whatever it may be.

Speaker:

W- were you able, able to ever get names or any further

Speaker:

information at all like that?

Speaker:

Uh, keep in mind it's a different community than, than, uh, the,

Speaker:

uh, the corner bar that you're gonna go and watch the, the

Speaker:

Sund- Sunday football game at.

Speaker:

Um, a lot of the men don't necessarily ask for names.

Speaker:

Um, they don't wanna know.

Speaker:

They don't need to know.

Speaker:

They're there for, um, a little bit of, uh, letdown time and

Speaker:

maybe find, find somebody to go home with for the night.

Speaker:

And, uh, many times they're not necessarily looking for

Speaker:

long-term relationships.

Speaker:

They're just looking for something for the night.

Speaker:

And so names, names weren't that important

Speaker:

You know, Mike, um, uh, I wanna go back to when Dahmer was arrested.

Speaker:

Um, you mentioned that he almost was glad that it was over.

Speaker:

Uh, sounds like he, he gave up.

Speaker:

He was okay being caught.

Speaker:

Um, I assume then he probably did not lawyer up.

Speaker:

He might have been forthcoming when, when he was interviewed by

Speaker:

either you or other detectives.

Speaker:

Can you, uh, tell us a little bit about that part of the process?

Speaker:

Um, Pat Kennedy was the detective that went downtown with him

Speaker:

and started talking to him.

Speaker:

Um, as I said, he, uh, advised him of his, uh, Miranda rights

Speaker:

and, uh, within probably, uh, 40, 45 minutes from them leaving

Speaker:

the apartment, uh, Dahmer, uh, Kennedy had called back and says,

Speaker:

"Hey, uh, he signed my book, given us permission to search

Speaker:

the apartment and take whatever evidence we wanted to take."

Speaker:

Um, and at that point, um, we were good to go.

Speaker:

Wow.

Speaker:

How much wa- how much of a media circus was the trial?

Speaker:

Oh,

Speaker:

there, there were, there were trailers from every, uh, news

Speaker:

network, um, that could get inside the building, um, with their, uh,

Speaker:

big dishes, uh, casting it out.

Speaker:

State Street, in front of the police station, in front of the

Speaker:

courthouse, um, was, uh, parked up both sides with, uh, media

Speaker:

vans and trucks and trailers.

Speaker:

What the case cost the detectives who worked it. A psychiatrist

Speaker:

who had seen one autopsy. And Officer Michael Michalski — family,

Speaker:

and a name on the National Law Enforcement Officers Memorial.

Speaker:

That's part two.

Speaker:

Subscribe so you don't miss it.

Speaker:

Thank you for joining us on Heroes Behind the Badge.

Speaker:

If you stand with the men and women who wear the badge, add

Speaker:

your name to the declaration of support at behindbadge.org.

Speaker:

There's another story waiting for you.

Speaker:

Stay with us.

Show artwork for Heroes Behind the Badge

About the Podcast

Heroes Behind the Badge
We tell REAL stories about REAL cops.  And we expose the fake news about police and give you the REAL truth.
From the front lines to the final call, Heroes Behind the Badge brings you the untold stories of America's law enforcement community. Led by Craig Floyd, who spent 34 years working alongside police officers across the nation, alongside veteran facilitator Dennis Collins and law enforcement expert Bill Erfurth, this podcast cuts through misconceptions to reveal the true nature of modern policing.

Our dynamic trio brings unique perspectives to each episode: Craig shares deep insights from his decades of experience and relationships within law enforcement, Dennis guides conversations with meticulous research and natural flow, and Bill adds engaging commentary that makes complex law enforcement topics accessible to all listeners.

Each episode features in-depth conversations with law enforcement professionals, sharing their firsthand experiences, challenges, and triumphs. Drawing from extensive research and real-world experience, we explore the realities faced by the over 800,000 officers who serve and protect our communities every day.

From dramatic accounts of crisis response to quiet moments of everyday heroism, our show illuminates the human stories behind the badge. We dive deep into the statistics, policies, and practices that shape modern law enforcement, offering listeners a comprehensive understanding of what it truly means to serve in law enforcement today.

Whether you're a law enforcement professional, a concerned citizen, or someone seeking to understand the complexities of modern policing, Heroes Behind the Badge provides the context, insights, and authentic perspectives you won't find anywhere else. Join us weekly as we honor those who dedicate their lives to keeping our communities safe, one story at a time.

Presented by Citizens Behind the Badge, a nonprofit organization dedicated to supporting and advocating for law enforcement professionals across the United States. Join over 126,000 Americans who have already signed our Declaration of Support for law enforcement at behindbadge.org.