Episode 72

full
Published on:

24th Sep 2026

Bill Bratton — Sweet Alice, the Bronx, and What the Job Costs | Part 2

Bill Bratton led six police departments over fifty years, including the NYPD twice and the LAPD from 2002 to 2009. In the second half of this conversation, the policy arguments give way to the people who shaped him — and to the parts of the job that no one applies for.

It opens in Watts. When Bratton arrived in Los Angeles, his community relations sergeant told him to go see Sweet Alice, a sharecropper's daughter from the South who had become the driving force of one of the city's most distressed neighborhoods. She once stood up at a community meeting and told an activist attacking the new chief to shut up. When Bratton left the city in 2009, she told him why her neighborhood had trusted him, in three words he still calls the highest honor of his career.

From there he turns to training, and to the difference between the departments he ran. The NYPD he took over in the 1990s was reactive and discouraged; the LAPD was proud, self-reliant and permanently short of officers, working with a fraction of the numbers he believes it needed. His own academy in Boston in 1970 lasted seven weeks. He argues the country still undertrains its police, and that the cost falls on officers first. Asked for his best moments, he describes lowering his gun in front of an armed man holding a bank teller hostage, and the 2007 MacArthur Park crisis he says was his finest hour as a chief.

Then the worst. For Bratton it is not a single moment but every officer he had to bury, and one night in 1994 when a young officer's widow arrived at a Bronx hospital still in her waitress uniform. He has carried what he heard in that hallway for thirty-two years.

He closes with Steven McDonald, the NYPD detective paralyzed in 1986 who publicly forgave the teenager who shot him, and who rode 235 miles by ambulance to attend Bratton's father's funeral. Across both parts, this is a portrait of a leader who changed American policing and remains unsentimental about what that took.

New episodes drop every other Tuesday and Thursday. Subscribe wherever you listen to podcasts.

Learn more at https://heroesbehindthebadge.com.

© 2026 Citizens Behind the Badge. All Rights Reserved.

Transcript
Speaker:

And as she's coming down the hall, she still had her waitress

Speaker:

uniform and her waitress bib on, as I guess you'd call it,

Speaker:

and the only sounds you could hear was, one, she wasn't

Speaker:

sure what she was coming to.

Speaker:

She had not been informed that her husband, in fact, was

Speaker:

deceased, was basically the clinking of the coins in her apron

Speaker:

50 years in six police departments.

Speaker:

This is the part of the job nobody applies for.

Speaker:

Yeah, I wanted to jump back to, uh, your time in LA.

Speaker:

Uh, I, I- I

Speaker:

had a great time.

Speaker:

I had a, I had a great time in LA.

Speaker:

Loved it out there.

Speaker:

Well, I, I came across a, a young lady by the name of Sweet Alice.

Speaker:

Do you know who I'm talking about?

Speaker:

Sweet- Oh, Sweet

Speaker:

Alice, certainly one of the most lovely, uh, community- Yeah

Speaker:

… organizers you could ever meet.

Speaker:

You were talking about community relations and, you know, how it's,

Speaker:

it, it is not what it should be.

Speaker:

Tell us the story about Sweet Alice and what that meant from a

Speaker:

community relations standpoint.

Speaker:

In the, uh, south part of Los Angeles where the bulk of the

Speaker:

African American population lived.

Speaker:

That population has now declined dramatically.

Speaker:

It's largely a Latino area now, South LA Watts.

Speaker:

Uh, Sweet Alice was a force of nature.

Speaker:

She grew up, uh, on a sharecropper farm down in

Speaker:

the South, experienced all the racial segregation of the

Speaker:

'50s, '60s, and like so many, fled that to go to California.

Speaker:

Wow.

Speaker:

In California, she moved into Watts, into one of the most

Speaker:

distressed areas, and, uh, effectively became an incredible

Speaker:

driving force, a social worker that, in her neighborhood.

Speaker:

And, uh, helping out, uh, the, the, in that poverty-stricken

Speaker:

area, and became a spokesperson for it, uh, had, uh,

Speaker:

daycare centers, et cetera.

Speaker:

And my first experience with her when I came into Los Angeles

Speaker:

2002, Fred Booker, the sergeant in charge of my community

Speaker:

relations here, an African American, one of the greatest

Speaker:

cops that ever was, says, "You need to go talk to Sweet Alice.

Speaker:

She can give you the real story about what's happening in,

Speaker:

uh, Watts, why it's happening, what's, why it's not happening."

Speaker:

Sure.

Speaker:

And, uh, I went down with my wife, uh, Rikki, uh, who used to go to

Speaker:

many of these meetings with me.

Speaker:

And we had, um… I'm, I'm, I'm pretty smart.

Speaker:

I bring Rikki oftentimes to a lot of the things I go to because you

Speaker:

cannot, as Craig can attest, you cannot help but to, to love Rikki.

Speaker:

And- … uh, Rikki is a great icebreaker with all the, uh,

Speaker:

uh, minority, uh, population that I dealt with in LA.

Speaker:

But, uh, we fell in love with Sweet Alice.

Speaker:

She had this delightful Southern accent, and it just…

Speaker:

Not, not, not well-educated.

Speaker:

I don't think she ever finished high school.

Speaker:

Uh, but she had street smarts, and she had goodwill smarts.

Speaker:

And I can remember, um, uh, attending a Christmas party she

Speaker:

hosted every year where she'd raise funds to give out gifts

Speaker:

to these hundreds of kids in s- uh, at Watts who would at

Speaker:

Christmas time not get anything.

Speaker:

And you'd see these kids come in, the clothes, the poor clothes

Speaker:

they're wearing and, and, um, uh, the gifts they were getting

Speaker:

were bicycles and high-end gifts.

Speaker:

And we ended up, uh, raising a lot of money with her,

Speaker:

but going to that Christmas party, uh, each year was

Speaker:

just a memorable experience.

Speaker:

But she was the heart and soul of the community that, uh- Yeah

Speaker:

… I'll never forget, we were at a community meeting and I had a, uh,

Speaker:

Black activist who was going after me and, um, uh, and Sweet Alice

Speaker:

got up and said, "You shut up."

Speaker:

And she says- We, we like this police chief.

Speaker:

We got his back.

Speaker:

And he shut up.

Speaker:

Wow.

Speaker:

'Cause, uh, s- Sweet Alice was a power unto herself.

Speaker:

So who's the real boss?

Speaker:

I guess it was Alice, huh?

Speaker:

You think… And I invited her and I, I, I hosted a Christmas

Speaker:

party every year, uh, with the LA Police Foundation, invited

Speaker:

a lot of the, uh, activists, uh, to that Christmas party.

Speaker:

It was a wonderful time, 3, 400 cops and political activists

Speaker:

and, uh, uh, social workers.

Speaker:

A great, great party.

Speaker:

And, uh, Sweet Alice would come.

Speaker:

But when Rikki and I were leaving LA in 2009, went down to say

Speaker:

goodbye to Sweet Alice, and I write about this in my most

Speaker:

recent book, The Profession.

Speaker:

And Sweet Alice gives me a hug, and she says to me,

Speaker:

"You know, Chief, you know why we love you so much?"

Speaker:

With this lovely accent.

Speaker:

"No, Alice, why is that?" She said, " 'Cause you hear us."

Speaker:

Hmm.

Speaker:

"You hear us."

Speaker:

Wow.

Speaker:

Wow.

Speaker:

What, what, what a compliment that the idea that y- that,

Speaker:

that she understood that I did hear them, I did listen to

Speaker:

them, and I did respond to them.

Speaker:

And to have that recognized, you can, you could not… That's

Speaker:

probably one of the highest compliments in 50 years of

Speaker:

policing I've ever received.

Speaker:

And I've, I've got more medals and awards than you

Speaker:

can think of, but that, that oral compliment was about the

Speaker:

highest award I ever received.

Speaker:

Do you think that is common?

Speaker:

You know, we're, we're talking about now policing in the 2026

Speaker:

era as opposed to years ago.

Speaker:

Do you think that cops generally get the community?

Speaker:

Do they understand the community?

Speaker:

Do they listen to their communities?

Speaker:

I think that a lot of cops do, a lot don't.

Speaker:

Uh, policing attracts a wide variety of, uh, people.

Speaker:

Uh, you get crime fighters, you get cops who are great community

Speaker:

activists, you get, uh… And, uh- The profession itself has changed

Speaker:

dramatically in the 50, 60 years I've been associated with it.

Speaker:

It is a much more caring, understanding, appreciative, uh,

Speaker:

learning profession than it had been prior to the '60s and '70s.

Speaker:

Uh, individually, uh, I have run across more good cops

Speaker:

than bad cops, certainly, uh, uncaring cops that, uh… And

Speaker:

it's a profession that requires a wide variety of people.

Speaker:

But, uh, the vast majority, I think, still come into the

Speaker:

profession the same way I did in 1970, because you w- you

Speaker:

wanted to make a difference.

Speaker:

You wanted a- Right … a, a good job.

Speaker:

You wanted a degree of security that it provides.

Speaker:

But it was also a job that you could have at the end of your

Speaker:

20 or 30 years, and I talk about this oftentimes in my retirement

Speaker:

speeches to retirees going off the job, that where else can

Speaker:

you have a job that every day you have the opportunity to

Speaker:

have a life of significance?

Speaker:

Every day you're doing something different, and every once in a

Speaker:

while that something different is of such significance that it

Speaker:

is incredibly impactful on you and the people you're dealing

Speaker:

with, that, uh, there's very few professions where you can have

Speaker:

that opportunity of every day having a day of significance and

Speaker:

ultimately a life of significance.

Speaker:

Did LA, uh, Bill get a different, um, a different guy,

Speaker:

a different leader than New York when you transitioned to LA?

Speaker:

It was a- Was Bill Bratton a different guy?

Speaker:

It was a different set of challenges.

Speaker:

Uh, the culture of the LAPD was very different than

Speaker:

the culture of the NYPD.

Speaker:

The NYPD I went into in the '80, uh, excuse me, the '90s,

Speaker:

was a very reactive, uh, discouraged police organization.

Speaker:

Mm.

Speaker:

It had been discouraged from the se- because of corruption

Speaker:

issues, racism issues, in the '80s in particular, from

Speaker:

being particularly proactive.

Speaker:

It was, uh, uh, in some respects overly supervised in

Speaker:

that officers were discouraged from, uh, engaging in a lot

Speaker:

of proactive activities.

Speaker:

Uh, it was, uh… And also the fact the sheer size of it, that

Speaker:

it, it w- and the reputation, NYPD, biggest and the best-

Speaker:

Yeah … that, uh, it had a, uh, a culture of superiority.

Speaker:

The LAPD, uh, was a organization that prided itself on its

Speaker:

professionalism, and the fact that there were so few of them compared

Speaker:

to other police departments on a per, uh, cop ratio.

Speaker:

Uh, the unofficial motto, the, the official motto was to

Speaker:

protect and serve on the side door of every car out there.

Speaker:

Right.

Speaker:

But the unofficial motto that Jimmy McDonnell, the current

Speaker:

chief, uh, who worked with me as, in the Boston Police

Speaker:

Department back in the '70s, uh, as Jimmy informed me when I came

Speaker:

in, uh, 2002, our unofficial motto was, "Too few who for

Speaker:

too long have been asked to do too much with too little."

Speaker:

Wow.

Speaker:

There was the LAPD.

Speaker:

It, always in budget crises.

Speaker:

Uh, with the force, when I joined it, they had 9,200,

Speaker:

and I spent the next seven years getting it up to 10,000.

Speaker:

But to have equivalent numbers to what I had to work with in

Speaker:

New York, taking into account population, land mass, et cetera,

Speaker:

I should have had 18,000 cops.

Speaker:

Wow.

Speaker:

Jimmy right now is working with 8,300 cops.

Speaker:

He's lost 1,000 cops because of George Floyd and a

Speaker:

lot of other things that have gone on out there.

Speaker:

And it's an extraordinary department that is probably

Speaker:

still the best-trained department in America, uh,

Speaker:

even superior to the NYPD.

Speaker:

NYPD does a great job with a lot of their specialized units,

Speaker:

but in general, the training is nowhere near the level of, uh,

Speaker:

intimacy that the LAPD, because of its smaller size, uh, uh,

Speaker:

gives and places on retraining in terms of, uh, year after year.

Speaker:

There's also the idea- That, uh, officers out there are very

Speaker:

self-reliant, at least the ones I was exposed to during my time.

Speaker:

Because on any given night, uh, those two cops in

Speaker:

that car, and they refer to each other as partner.

Speaker:

Partner this, partner that.

Speaker:

They don't g- call each other by first names.

Speaker:

Uh, every LA cop wears his uniform exactly the same way.

Speaker:

Wow.

Speaker:

If you look at them, the, the two spare rounds, uh, clips on their

Speaker:

belt where the handcuffs are.

Speaker:

Why is that?

Speaker:

That's the training.

Speaker:

If in the middle of the night you guys are engaged in some

Speaker:

type of shootout or something, you wanna be able to basically,

Speaker:

if you need to get stuff off the other officer's belt- Sure

Speaker:

you know where it is.

Speaker:

And they, they back each other up.

Speaker:

It's, it's a much more intimate organization.

Speaker:

And I would… It's… You know how you have pride

Speaker:

in every child you have?

Speaker:

Well, I've been chief of six different departments, and I

Speaker:

have pride in each of those six.

Speaker:

That's right.

Speaker:

But I'll tell you, the six were, uh, a couple of them

Speaker:

were prob- problem children.

Speaker:

But a couple of them- No doubt.

Speaker:

Yeah … outstanding in the sense of, uh, uh,

Speaker:

exceptional in some respects.

Speaker:

Interesting.

Speaker:

You know, you, you talk about training, Bill.

Speaker:

I, I think I remember you saying somewhere you had several weeks

Speaker:

of training, a few weeks of training before you were handed a

Speaker:

gun and a badge in Boston- Indeed

Speaker:

uh, back in 1970.

Speaker:

And, and you were recommending that really the ideal training

Speaker:

period should last one year.

Speaker:

Is, is that right?

Speaker:

That's correct.

Speaker:

When I joined the Boston Police Department at, uh, on, uh,

Speaker:

October 7th, one day after my 23rd birthday, uh, we were

Speaker:

out on the streets in time for Thanksgiving that year.

Speaker:

So what's that?

Speaker:

Seven weeks in our blue uniforms with our six-shot revolvers, my

Speaker:

badge 1190 patrolman, my whistle.

Speaker:

And, uh, two weeks after that, after two weeks of

Speaker:

directing traffic, I was in plainclothes wandering through

Speaker:

the subways and the stores in downtown Boston looking

Speaker:

for pickpockets and thieves-

Speaker:

Wow

Speaker:

with, with, with the most minimum of training.

Speaker:

Just think of that.

Speaker:

23 years old, all 150 pounds of me, the awesome powers

Speaker:

and authority I'd been given with no training t-

Speaker:

basically to back it up.

Speaker:

Uh, I've always been an advocate of much more significant training.

Speaker:

On average, I think, in the United States, we try to give about

Speaker:

six months of s- uh, training.

Speaker:

Um, I try to expand that in New York.

Speaker:

New York recently has basically had to reduce it because of

Speaker:

some of the personnel shortages.

Speaker:

Same for LAPD.

Speaker:

They've all, all pulled back, and I think that's unfortunately

Speaker:

one of the biggest mistakes we make in policing, and one of

Speaker:

the biggest mistake politicians and the public make, not

Speaker:

appreciating, uh, the need for adequate funding and time to

Speaker:

train and to continue to retrain.

Speaker:

Just think of all the renewed respons- new responsibilities

Speaker:

just in the last couple years that we need to impart to these

Speaker:

young officers that we don't have the time to do it 'cause we're so

Speaker:

shorthanded to put cops in cars.

Speaker:

They're not at the academy long enough initially, and

Speaker:

certainly not long enough as they're going forward.

Speaker:

And the key to it is, would you wanna go to a doctor who

Speaker:

basically, uh, uh, went to medical school, but then all

Speaker:

of a sudden he's now out there practicing after only going to

Speaker:

medical school without doing his internships, et cetera?

Speaker:

You damn sure wouldn't wanna go to that doctor.

Speaker:

Mm.

Speaker:

So we are under, under-trained, uh, as a whole in the United

Speaker:

States, and a v- most recent example of that is what's gone

Speaker:

on with the, uh, with ICE, with that, uh, unfortunate expansion

Speaker:

of 20,000 people they've hired or something in a, in

Speaker:

less than a couple of months.

Speaker:

Uh, they had a, uh, if I understand it, a

Speaker:

47-day training period.

Speaker:

Why 47 days?

Speaker:

Well, President of the United States is the 47th president.

Speaker:

47.

Speaker:

Yeah,

Speaker:

makes sense, yeah.

Speaker:

That, that, some, some genius at, uh, ICE decided, "Well,

Speaker:

let's, let's train them for 47 days." 47 days and they're

Speaker:

out there, and we're seeing on television what lack of

Speaker:

training, uh, ends up doing when they're out on the street faced

Speaker:

with, uh, the challenges that they're facing on the street.

Speaker:

No, um, training is ABT, always be training.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

But unfortunately, uh, we don't.

Speaker:

And that's, that's the-

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

That is one of my great- Yeah … regrets that, uh, while I've been

Speaker:

an advocate for it, while I was at the NYPD, LAPD, I was able to

Speaker:

expand it for a period of time.

Speaker:

Both organizations, because of budget pressures and personnel

Speaker:

shortages, have had to pull back on it, and, and that creates just

Speaker:

great risk for the officers and for the profession as a whole.

Speaker:

For sure,

Speaker:

yeah.

Speaker:

Bill, I, I don't wanna let you go without asking this, uh, im-

Speaker:

important question, I think, and, and maybe a, a question for

Speaker:

reflection, and that is, uh, in your 50 years of policing, can you

Speaker:

identify the best moment and maybe the worst moment in your career?

Speaker:

Best moments, I think, um, ones where I was

Speaker:

professionally challenged.

Speaker:

One would be the idea of as a, as a cop, you always understand

Speaker:

you're gonna deal with danger, and how are you gonna react to it.

Speaker:

It's like w- when you're in the military that, uh, my,

Speaker:

my, uh, three years in the US Army and a year in Vietnam.

Speaker:

And so in terms of that issue that's always so important to

Speaker:

cops, this idea of being able to handle yourself, probably a

Speaker:

satisfactory moment was the, uh, just shortly after going through

Speaker:

hostage negotiation training, encountering a bank holdup

Speaker:

suspect holding a hostage with a gun to her head, a bank teller,

Speaker:

uh, that I confronted as a young sergeant, and was able to, uh,

Speaker:

y- y- see my training kick in.

Speaker:

Now, in appreciation of the training issue we were just

Speaker:

talking about, and what was that training that kicked in?

Speaker:

In a hostage situation, one, try not to expose yourself personally

Speaker:

to the, the hostage taker.

Speaker:

My case, unfortunately, I ended up confronting him, both of us

Speaker:

pointing guns at each other.

Speaker:

I couldn't hit the broad side of a barn with a .38, which I was

Speaker:

carrying at that time, and, uh, so the gun was useless to me.

Speaker:

I'd kill the hostage before I'd end up killing him.

Speaker:

And so my training was reduce the tension wherever you can.

Speaker:

So while I'm trying to reduce the tension by talking, by

Speaker:

lowering my gun, it reduced his tension somewhat.

Speaker:

And so it's an experience that, uh, reinforced the issue

Speaker:

about training, reinforced my sense of my skill with

Speaker:

the training I'd received, uh, testing your bravery.

Speaker:

I got, I got the, uh, department's highest award for valor, uh,

Speaker:

named after two Boston police officers, brothers killed in

Speaker:

the line of duty, the Schroeder brothers- Oh … uh, medal

Speaker:

for that. So that was a test.

Speaker:

The second test was, uh, uh, of significant leadership

Speaker:

skills, and that was in 2007.

Speaker:

I'm up for my reappointment as chief of the Los

Speaker:

Angeles Police Department.

Speaker:

I'd been going through a whole series of community meetings, and,

Speaker:

uh, I basically had it locked up.

Speaker:

Uh, the police commission was going to reappoint me,

Speaker:

and then on May Day of 2007, uh, we had a tremendous, um,

Speaker:

what has been described as a police riot in MacArthur Park.

Speaker:

Uh, tens of thousands of Latinos, families in the park celebrating

Speaker:

May Day, and because a group of anarchists had basically assaulted

Speaker:

officers at one end of the park, the commanding officer authorized,

Speaker:

uh, and led effectively a clean out the park sweep by

Speaker:

the metro unit of the LAPD.

Speaker:

And in that clean out, uh, they fired over 250 rounds

Speaker:

from their, uh, the, the rubber pellets, uh, exer- exercised

Speaker:

a lot of use of their batons, and, uh, it was a mess.

Speaker:

Hmm.

Speaker:

And, uh, I really believe that was, in my police career, um,

Speaker:

what I would describe as my finest hour, facing that chan-

Speaker:

challenge, because in that park was a media tent with some of

Speaker:

the top media from all over Latin America, was in that tent, and

Speaker:

they were overrun by the police, and it was all captured on film.

Speaker:

My mayor was in Latin America celebrating, the

Speaker:

first Latino mayor of LA.

Speaker:

I was gonna join him that night because he was on a victory

Speaker:

lap about how things were going so well, and meanwhile,

Speaker:

he has all this television beaming back to where he

Speaker:

is about this police riot.

Speaker:

Oh.

Speaker:

So I had Latino media upset.

Speaker:

I had my police commission upset, my inspector general

Speaker:

upset, my city council upset, my cops upset because I wasn't

Speaker:

defending their actions.

Speaker:

I was- Right … criticizing, not necessarily just their actions,

Speaker:

but the leadership in particular.

Speaker:

So, um, the turnaround of that situation, where I saved my

Speaker:

chief's job, uh, was probably my proudest moment as a chief

Speaker:

of police in dealing with a crisis, in that we did an

Speaker:

after action report that was widely applauded, uh, for its

Speaker:

truthfulness, its forcefulness, and the changes we made.

Speaker:

Uh, so much so that it never required an outside investigation.

Speaker:

They were comfortable for the first time with the

Speaker:

internal investigation.

Speaker:

So I've had a lot of successes, a lot of failures.

Speaker:

Uh, I try to learn from the failures, but those two stand out,

Speaker:

uh- Wow … in police policing, the issue of how are you gonna

Speaker:

handle yourself in a moment of physical- Threat and challenge.

Speaker:

And how are you gonna handle yourself in a moment of political,

Speaker:

intellectual, strategic challenge?

Speaker:

Wow.

Speaker:

And, um, uh-

Speaker:

Great examples.

Speaker:

How about the worst moment?

Speaker:

You, you talk about the best.

Speaker:

What, what was maybe a moment that keeps you awake at, at night?

Speaker:

W- w- worst, worst moment is not a moment, many moments, and that's

Speaker:

the, the death of police officers.

Speaker:

Right.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Um, and- Worst … you can say in, uh, some 50 years

Speaker:

associated with policing, with 25 of them actively as a

Speaker:

chief, uh, I've had to respond to the deaths of many officers

Speaker:

in those, those departments.

Speaker:

And the worst moments are the response initially, uh, dealing

Speaker:

with the families as they're arriving at the hospitals, and

Speaker:

then delivering the eulogies.

Speaker:

Delivering eulogies is extraordinarily difficult.

Speaker:

Every chief will tell you that.

Speaker:

That because all eyes are upon you and finding the

Speaker:

appropriate words in the moments.

Speaker:

But then remembering, uh, those memories stay with you,

Speaker:

the response to those scenes and how horrific they can be.

Speaker:

Probably one that's, one that stands out, uh, most

Speaker:

for me was the death of the first officer in 1994.

Speaker:

Uh, young, young kid, uh, killed up in the Bronx,

Speaker:

uh, during a hold-up.

Speaker:

And I'm in the hospital room with him, he is now deceased,

Speaker:

we have the priest and some of my command staff, and we had

Speaker:

sent a helicopter up to get his wife that, uh, he was… That

Speaker:

she, they were living upstate.

Speaker:

And it's quiet in the hospital.

Speaker:

Hundreds of officers outside in the halls in New York

Speaker:

when it happens that they come from everywhere.

Speaker:

And, but then she arrives, and it's, it,

Speaker:

everything just goes quiet.

Speaker:

Not a sound, out of respect for her.

Speaker:

And she had- She was a waitress.

Speaker:

She had been picked up where she was working that night.

Speaker:

And as she's coming down the hall, she still had her waitress

Speaker:

uniform and her waitress bib on, as I guess you'd call it.

Speaker:

And the only sounds you could hear was, one, she wasn't

Speaker:

sure what she was coming to.

Speaker:

She had not been informed that her husband, in fact, was deceased.

Speaker:

Was basically the clinking of the coins in her apron.

Speaker:

Hmm.

Speaker:

That, uh, the change.

Speaker:

That was the only sounds you could hear as she came into the

Speaker:

room, the, the sound of that, and just, and it stayed with me for…

Speaker:

That would've been 1994.

Speaker:

What's that?

Speaker:

32 years ago.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

That's, um… So there's many worst moments that,

Speaker:

uh, uh, each of them, um-

Speaker:

N- none of them good memories in the sense of, uh, uh, when

Speaker:

you're dealing with the death of an officer, none of them are good.

Speaker:

What about, uh, and last question, um, Steven McDonald

Speaker:

is one of those officers who died in the line of duty.

Speaker:

You had a lot of interaction with Steven.

Speaker:

Th- this is an amazing story.

Speaker:

We call him God's cop because he, he preached, uh, forgiveness.

Speaker:

Uh, he was shot by a 15-year-old bike thief in Central Park

Speaker:

back in 1986, and, uh, was paralyzed from the neck

Speaker:

down, and, uh, soon after, forgave the man who shot him.

Speaker:

And, uh, it's an incredible story.

Speaker:

He lived for another 31 years, died in 2017 from the injuries

Speaker:

he suffered in that shooting.

Speaker:

Um, they just renamed the New York City Police

Speaker:

Department Police Academy-

Speaker:

After

Speaker:

Steven … after Steven.

Speaker:

I- I'd like you to comment on, on Steven, just to share

Speaker:

with our audience who this was and what that meant to

Speaker:

you when they renamed the police academy after him.

Speaker:

I was first introduced to him, him when I c- came to New York

Speaker:

for the first time in 1990 as chief of transit, and he was at,

Speaker:

uh, one of the events I attended.

Speaker:

Uh, his newborn son, I think the son was about five years

Speaker:

old at that time, that, uh- Oh, yeah … when he was shot, his

Speaker:

wife was, was pregnant and I think gave birth after, uh, he was shot.

Speaker:

Uh, his son recently has been promoted to a deputy inspector

Speaker:

in the NYPD, and, uh, great family, Patti, his wife.

Speaker:

And I had the honor of, uh, promoting Steven to, uh,

Speaker:

the rank of detective when I was police commissioner.

Speaker:

And, uh, just an incredible m- man.

Speaker:

NYPD is big enough that some of our severely injured officers,

Speaker:

we are actually able to keep them on the department where

Speaker:

they s- they s- uh, Steven did serve so many, uh, roles

Speaker:

as a goodwill ambassador, uh, at various public events.

Speaker:

A favorite memory of Steven, though, is, and this is a personal

Speaker:

one, that, uh, h- he's confined to a wheelchair, always basically

Speaker:

with the breathing tubes.

Speaker:

Uh, he could manipulate a few fingers that could control certain

Speaker:

features of it, but he's, he's confined to this wheelchair.

Speaker:

And, uh, they had a special ambulance for him to allow him

Speaker:

to be able to move around with the oxygen that, uh, he needed.

Speaker:

And my dad died in 2016 —

Speaker:

I was police commissioner — living up in, uh,

Speaker:

Weymouth, Massachusetts.

Speaker:

I'm down in New York.

Speaker:

I go up for Dad's funeral to put it together- And at Dad's, uh,

Speaker:

uh, wake and funeral, um, about 300, uh, New York City police

Speaker:

officers traveled from New York to come up, a lot of my command

Speaker:

staff to attend that funeral.

Speaker:

It was, uh, Dad was a Navy veteran, so he got military

Speaker:

send-off, et cetera.

Speaker:

But Steven came up in that ambulance, the 235-mile drive

Speaker:

from New York, and then 235 miles back, to come in and

Speaker:

basically attend those services.

Speaker:

That- that's- that's, that's, you know, you can imagine

Speaker:

how that makes you feel in the sense of that degree

Speaker:

of- of love and respect.

Speaker:

Uh, and he- he's the embodiment of what policing,

Speaker:

uh, should be about.

Speaker:

Fortunately, the embodiment of much of what policing is

Speaker:

about, and is the embodiment of what the goal sh- should be

Speaker:

for every police officer, this idea of compassion, this idea of

Speaker:

having a life of significance.

Speaker:

Here's this paraplegic, and what a life of significance,

Speaker:

what a legacy he had.

Speaker:

Uh, you know, when, when I exit the stage, I wanna have

Speaker:

people say, uh, uh, uh, "What a, what a nice legacy that

Speaker:

guy left behind." Really.

Speaker:

It's never gonna match what Steve McDonald left behind, but

Speaker:

it's something to strive for.

Speaker:

He even, uh, gave the, uh, keynote address at the dedication

Speaker:

dinner for the National Law Enforcement Officers Memorial.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Mm-hmm.

Speaker:

And now his name is inscribed on that same memorial.

Speaker:

Uh, an incredible human being, and, uh, so glad

Speaker:

to have known him a bit.

Speaker:

Uh,

Speaker:

Bill-

Speaker:

Well, since this is my comment about the death of officers

Speaker:

being the most impactful, who knows more about that than you?

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

Really.

Speaker:

You've, you've committed your life to remembering every

Speaker:

police officer in the United States who's ever lost- Sure

Speaker:

a life in the service of the police profession.

Speaker:

So, uh, I hadn't thought of that when I, I mentioned that

Speaker:

about the impact of those on me, that nobody knows it better

Speaker:

than you, that's for sure.

Speaker:

Well, it's been an honor and a privilege to be able to honor

Speaker:

and remember those, uh, fallen heroes of law enforcement,

Speaker:

as well as those who continue to serve and risk their lives

Speaker:

daily for our protection.

Speaker:

Uh, Dennis, I'm gonna turn it over to you to close us out, but-

Speaker:

Well,

Speaker:

I- … uh, let me, let me suggest one thing, though, before I leave,

Speaker:

and that is, um, we call this show Heroes Behind the Badge.

Speaker:

I'm thinking today's episode should be called Legendary

Speaker:

Legends, uh, Legendary Leaders of the Badge.

Speaker:

And, uh- Legendary Leaders of the Badge.

Speaker:

I like that.

Speaker:

I, I think- We're gonna have to get a whole new, uh, logo here.

Speaker:

Uh, Drew will do that for us.

Speaker:

But, uh, no, I, I thank you, Bill.

Speaker:

You've been amazing- Appreciate that … uh, a

Speaker:

part of my life, and I'm so glad you joined us today.

Speaker:

Thank you.

Speaker:

But I have, Commissioner, I have one final question.

Speaker:

Maybe you'll break some news here today.

Speaker:

Are you still hungry?

Speaker:

Are you going to take another shot at it?

Speaker:

I wish I were 10 year- I, I oftentimes talk about this.

Speaker:

I wish I was 10 years younger.

Speaker:

Um, I'll, I'll be 79 this October 6th.

Speaker:

Wow.

Speaker:

And, uh, I'll be very frank with you, the… I think the intellect

Speaker:

is better than it was in 1970.

Speaker:

The- I don't think there's been no diminishing, and

Speaker:

it's in- informed by 50-some odd years of experience.

Speaker:

Absolutely.

Speaker:

Uh, uh, the energy level relative to intellectually is still there.

Speaker:

But, uh, the job itself, even as a police chief, a police leader,

Speaker:

is physically extraordinarily demanding in the sense of- Right

Speaker:

… from, you know, 5:00 in the morning till 10, 11:00 at night,

Speaker:

the various events, benefits you have to go to, engagements, 3:00

Speaker:

in the morning calls, officers shot, going to the hospital.

Speaker:

It is a physically very taxing job.

Speaker:

And so, um, would I love to be back in the day, back in the game?

Speaker:

You better believe it.

Speaker:

Miss it every day, particularly when you look at the,

Speaker:

the life I've had, NYPD, Boston- Right … LAPD.

Speaker:

Uh, uh, been an extraordinary life with a lot of, uh,

Speaker:

quite a rollercoaster ride.

Speaker:

Yeah.

Speaker:

And, uh, uh, but I'm not so sure that intellectually

Speaker:

could I contribute?

Speaker:

Yes.

Speaker:

But physically, no.

Speaker:

So intellectually- Right … I do attempt to

Speaker:

stay involved with- Absolutely … appearances like this.

Speaker:

I do a lot of op-eds.

Speaker:

I still teach at PERF's SMIP every year.

Speaker:

Uh, I still do a lot of mentoring, an awful lot of mentoring,

Speaker:

which, uh, I thoroughly enjoy.

Speaker:

Uh, uh, until my time comes to go, I, I, I intend to

Speaker:

try and stay impactful.

Speaker:

Uh, we, we hope so.

Speaker:

I think we, we the citizens of the United States and those

Speaker:

who are, who are involved in policing are better for your

Speaker:

involvement, and I hope you'll stay involved for a long time.

Speaker:

Please mention your book again.

Speaker:

Uh, your lat- I know you have several, but your

Speaker:

latest book, I believe, was called The Profession, right?

Speaker:

Right.

Speaker:

There were three of them.

Speaker:

I was fortunate to work with three great co-authors.

Speaker:

First one was Turnaround, after I thought I was leaving policing

Speaker:

in 1996, uh, with Peter Knobler.

Speaker:

Right.

Speaker:

Uh, that was a biography.

Speaker:

Second one was, uh, was, uh, Zach Tumin in 2012, a police

Speaker:

management book, uh, called Collaborate or Perish, the theme

Speaker:

of collaboration essentiality.

Speaker:

Right.

Speaker:

And the third one, the most recent, and thank you for

Speaker:

mentioning, is The Profession.

Speaker:

It's a memoir.

Speaker:

Uh, it's not just my story.

Speaker:

It's many stories of many people that were impactful in my career

Speaker:

and on the profession itself.

Speaker:

And so, uh, all three of them… And that's part of the legacy

Speaker:

that, uh, a lot of chiefs will be able to get a book out there.

Speaker:

I've been the great fortune of getting three of them out.

Speaker:

That's great.

Speaker:

And Craig, uh, I think you're well aware that an honor that I

Speaker:

received this past, uh, uh, summer was at the Police Memorial event.

Speaker:

I received from, uh, the Police Memorial people a, uh, one

Speaker:

of their awards for, uh, the service to policing, and I was-

Speaker:

Lifetime achievement, I believe.

Speaker:

Yep.

Speaker:

I was very,

Speaker:

very humbled- As you deserve

Speaker:

very humbled by that one.

Speaker:

That, uh, uh… That's quite an award.

Speaker:

It weighs about 50 pounds trying to lug that thing around.

Speaker:

You can credit me for that or blame me, yeah.

Speaker:

Well, um, again, thank you, uh, for being with us.

Speaker:

I mean, this is an honor to have you.

Speaker:

It's an honor to get to know you, the person behind all

Speaker:

these headlines that have been created over the years, and

Speaker:

thank you for sharing that.

Speaker:

Person behind the badge, badge 1190.

Speaker:

You got it, 1190.

Speaker:

Thank you.

Speaker:

I, I, I figured that out.

Speaker:

I researched that.

Speaker:

I had to know that badge

Speaker:

number, so.

Speaker:

So again, thank you again.

Speaker:

I want to remind our, uh, listeners and our viewers, this

Speaker:

is Heroes Behind the Badge.

Speaker:

If you liked anything that Commissioner Bill Bratton had

Speaker:

to say today, and there was a whole lot to like, will you

Speaker:

subscribe, like, and follow?

Speaker:

Yeah, subscribe, like, and follow Heroes Behind the Badge.

Speaker:

Okay?

Speaker:

We are sponsored by Citizens Behind the Badge.

Speaker:

Citizens Behind the Badge is the leading organization

Speaker:

in support of the men and women of law enforcement.

Speaker:

Join hundreds of thousands of your fellow Americans in support

Speaker:

of law enforcement by going on

Speaker:

citizensbehindthebadge.org, citizensbehindthebadge.org.

Speaker:

You will find all about us.

Speaker:

You'll also have a tab for this podcast so that you never

Speaker:

miss the next episode, and we release quite a few new ones.

Speaker:

Uh, and this one is going to, uh, this one is going to be one that

Speaker:

a lot of people wanna listen to.

Speaker:

So- Again, we appreciate your listening.

Speaker:

It's citizensbehindthebadge.org.

Speaker:

This episode of Heroes Behind the Badge is now over.

Speaker:

Thank you, Commissioner Bill Bratton.

Speaker:

Thank you.

Speaker:

We appreciate, we appreciate you, and we'll see you next

Speaker:

time on Heroes Behind the Badge.

Show artwork for Heroes Behind the Badge

About the Podcast

Heroes Behind the Badge
We tell REAL stories about REAL cops.  And we expose the fake news about police and give you the REAL truth.
From the front lines to the final call, Heroes Behind the Badge brings you the untold stories of America's law enforcement community. Led by Craig Floyd, who spent 34 years working alongside police officers across the nation, alongside veteran facilitator Dennis Collins and law enforcement expert Bill Erfurth, this podcast cuts through misconceptions to reveal the true nature of modern policing.

Our dynamic trio brings unique perspectives to each episode: Craig shares deep insights from his decades of experience and relationships within law enforcement, Dennis guides conversations with meticulous research and natural flow, and Bill adds engaging commentary that makes complex law enforcement topics accessible to all listeners.

Each episode features in-depth conversations with law enforcement professionals, sharing their firsthand experiences, challenges, and triumphs. Drawing from extensive research and real-world experience, we explore the realities faced by the over 800,000 officers who serve and protect our communities every day.

From dramatic accounts of crisis response to quiet moments of everyday heroism, our show illuminates the human stories behind the badge. We dive deep into the statistics, policies, and practices that shape modern law enforcement, offering listeners a comprehensive understanding of what it truly means to serve in law enforcement today.

Whether you're a law enforcement professional, a concerned citizen, or someone seeking to understand the complexities of modern policing, Heroes Behind the Badge provides the context, insights, and authentic perspectives you won't find anywhere else. Join us weekly as we honor those who dedicate their lives to keeping our communities safe, one story at a time.

Presented by Citizens Behind the Badge, a nonprofit organization dedicated to supporting and advocating for law enforcement professionals across the United States. Join over 126,000 Americans who have already signed our Declaration of Support for law enforcement at behindbadge.org.